Back when I was 20 and discussed love, life and everything else with my fellow students in Amsterdam I was the only one of my group of driven young women whose biggest ambition was to become a mother. Mother first, everything else second. I even said, something they still remind me of every now and then, that “If I haven’t found the right man by the time I’m 30, I’ll take them on my own”. Children I meant, not the men. Over the years that thought changed, mainly due to age and experience. Nothing quite like the self-centeredness of 20-year olds…
This was all challenged in my thirties when I didn’t get pregnant straight away. My younger sister got pregnant by just thinking about it, one of my friends fell pregnant through taking anti-conception and had it subsequently terminated and the same university friends who didn’t seem overly bothered about motherhood in the first place kept their pregnancies from me for the first months because, guess what, they all fell pregnant straight away.
I started the route of investigation and it turned out that both of us were fine, together it seemed to work but we were just one of these couples that took a bit longer. The fact we lived in separate countries probably didn’t help matters and I clearly remember the time where I HAD to travel to a certain country, in a certain week, just to have sex.
It took us three years but at last I was rewarded with healthy beautiful twins, luckily enough without IVF or such.
So when I saw an item on tv about the shortage of egg donors I immediately empathised with all those struggling couples. That same day I contacted a clinic to register as a potential donor.
I went through implication-counselling and was forced to think about the consequences for myself, my children, the donor conceived and the dc parents. I researched it as much as I could in the limited time I had. I was already 35, had 2 one-year olds, was going through a divorce and my company was about to go under. I could have been forgiven for not wanting to go ahead, but my desire to help was stronger than everything else. I thought it was the right thing to do.
During my research I stumbled across the NGDT and contacted them after I completed my donation. It was a slightly different type of organisation back then but I quickly became a Trustee. Some years later we were consulted about the removal of anonymity which caused a split between the Trustees. Some were fiercely against it, others were not so much against it but feared the end of donation altogether. I asked myself where I stood on the debate and sought consultation from many people around me. In the meantime I had met many donors, donor conceived young adults, recipients, clinicians, ethicists, researchers- you name them. I’ve learned a lot from listening to them and whilst I didn’t always agree, it certainly made me wiser and taught me more shades of grey than even I thought was possible.
I learned more about "genetic bewilderment" - the confusion of not knowing who your biological parent is. I’ve either spoken to, emailed with, learned from or heard from many donor conceived young adults, across the globe, and saw different reactions and emotions. From the not caring and happy to be alive, only curious on a superficial level, really wanting to find out and disappointed that they couldn’t, to being genuinely distressed and distraught about it. I’ve learned a lot from my closest friend who was told at the age of 16 that what he thought were his parents were not his biological parents. He now knows who is mother is but still knows nothing about his father. Interestingly enough, he was against removal of anonymity, adding another shade of grey to the spectrum.
I’ve either spoken to, emailed with, learned from or heard from many egg and sperm donors from all over the world. The vast majority is happy with their donation. A large percentage of donors would not donate on a willing to be known basis but have no regrets about what they did. There is a very small group that has regrets.
And I’ve either spoken to, emailed with, learned from or heard from thousands of recipients-to-be, people on waiting lists or people who abandoned treatment all together. To cut a long story short, I never met a happy one.
Consequently I fundamentally disagree with the conclusion of the comment left on an earlier post that “the most important concern in donor conception is the welfare of offspring”. I agree with the importance of their welfare but I disagree with the suggestion that all donor conceived children feel abandoned and that therefore donor assisted conception should be abolished.
I fully accept and understand that some donor conceived people may have certain needs that need to be met. I have therefore changed my status as a donor. I donated under the old law, i.e. I was anonymous, but am now registered as a willing-to-be-known donor. But I know the needs of people requiring donors as well and feel these needs should be equally met.
Unlike most donors I had and have to review my thoughts and actions several times. When I donated, when I became the Chair going through a legislation change, when I changed my own status as a donor and the numerous times I have been challenged. I’ve dealt with more people, pro and against, than I can remember and read more research on all sides of the argument than most people realise is available. Each and every time I learn something new and the way I think about it now is different from when I donated 7 years ago. But I still think it was the right thing to do. For me at least.
I realise that other people would have made different choices given the same information. That is their prerogative and I respect them for that. Life has taught me some invaluable lessons, one of them that others are not right or wrong. They just think differently about something.
Of course I hope that the children out of my donation are happy, healthy and safe. I don’t know whether the parents will tell them about their conception but for everybody’s sake I hope they do sooner rather than later. There is strong evidence to suggest that children who are told early in life about their conception have a greater acceptance. Furthermore, by not telling you risk the children finding out in a different way adding the issue of deception to an already bewildering situation.
And whether they are ‘just’ curious to find out about my basic statistics or want to meet me, it’s fine with me. Admittedly I would feel for the parents if they want to meet as I can imagine their anxiety about the bond the children may seek with me. Time will tell how I, and my family, will react and feel. I like to think I’m balanced and stable enough to be able to deal with any scenario that can be thrown at me.
About the criticism of my choice itself:
My life, my choices, my failures and my successes have always been met by criticism, (mis)judgement, jealousy, misunderstanding. It fits people’s own belief to think that my choices are not thought through – especially if they don’t agree with me -, all the good things in my life are down to sheer luck or good looks and that underneath this persona lurks another much darker creature. As a result, I have become desensitised when it comes to criticism.
I will never stop caring about people. But I have stopped caring what some say about me years ago.